Delimitation Bill - a debacle or a decoy?
The Government and the opposition went hammer and tongs (not quite literally) during the parliamentary debate on 131st Constitutional amendment, for the first time in 12 years, a bill tabled by the Modi Government was 'defeated' by the parliament as it failed to achieve the 2/3rd majority required for constitutional amendments.
The opposition is thumping their chest by saying 'They saved the Death of India's Democracy' while the BJP are claiming a 'moral victory'. "हार के भी जीत गए"
So what's the truth here? What's coming your way isn't less than an Aditya Dhar film. This has got several layers that I will try to peel one by one.
However, the bill clearly defined that this bill will only be implemented once the census and delimitation process is done and dusted.
Now, coming to delimitation, post the 1971 census, India froze the seat allocation according to population because it didn't want to penalize the states that controlled population growth. The delimitation 'freeze' was to end in 2026. Amit Shah had already given his word in the parliament that delimitation process would begin shortly.
That builds the ground for bringing the delimitation bill.
A BJP MP rang up a journalist three weeks ago to ask "Do you know why are they calling us on the 16th"? Apparently, the BJP MP had to travel to somewhere on the 16th. Imagine the confidentiality of the move that an MP from the ruling party didn't know what his party was tabling on the 16th. The most dangerous thing about this government is that it keeps everyone on their toes.
Now, let's talk about numbers. The BJP and their NDA allies have 293 members (on top of that, they have the support of 10 independents) taking their tally to 303. For a constitutional amendment to pass, support of 2/3rd i.e. 362 members in the parliament. The government were short of 59 supporting votes. So why did Modi and Shah, two of the shrewdest politicians in the history of Indian politics play a losing game?
CHAPTER 3: It's not over, till it's over
- Well Thought Chess Move: The Government knew all the cards that will unfold on the day of the debate. They deliberately tabled an incoherent and contentious bill by clubbing women's reservation along with delimitation. This would result in a staunch resistance from the opposition as it did. It's sad that we as citizens are mere 'pawns' while the politicians are the players but that's the harsh reality.
- Numbers Don't Lie: Also going by the 'guarantee' that Amit Shah was giving in the parliament, the seats of all the states would increase by 50%. The net effect of the share of power (Lok Sabha Seats/Total Seats) in the Southern states increases marginally or remains the same. Karnataka and Kerala gets the same share of seats. Tamil Nadu, Telangana and Andhra Pradesh gains marginally.
- The Narrative War: The choice of tabling this bill just a week before the first vote is polled in Tamil Nadu is an interesting one. The Southern states have been battling for higher representation in the parliament since years. This would have increased their seats and Modi-Shah could've set a narrative of being 'Inclusive', 'Responsive to South India's needs' just a week before the state elections. Remember that BJP has historically struggled politically in the Southern-regions of the country. This narrative could've helped BJP make a transition in the eyes of the voters from a 'North-Centric' party to an 'All Inclusive' party
- Sandbagging: The BJP has already got the ball rolling. Just moments after the bill got defeated, women BJP MPs started a protest against the opposition for opposing a bill as they say, empowered women to be the decision makers of our country. Women voters are a key vote-bank of both the TMC in West Bengal and the DMK in Tamil Nadu. This sets the stage for a political bout with Mamata Banerjee in West Bengal. The BJP is already all guns blazing with "We brought the bill for women, they opposed it" narrative all over their political campaigns.
I don't buy the fact that Modi-Shah duo didn't know that they'll lose the vote. They knew the outcome and deliberately played this political ploy to coerce the opposition in getting 'hitwicket'. I think women MPs who protested just after the vote outside the parliament had their placards ready. It was a tactic to gain political advantage, how much of an advantage will it give them? Only time will tell.
The opposition too can claim a small victory by acting as a united front unlike the crab mentality that they usually showcase in fighting the government.
The good part of this whole drama that unfolded was that no MPs behaved as hooligans for a change, no one jumped into the well to chant slogans, no one tore up the bill (like the crown prince did once against his own government's bill) and for a change, parliament had a healthy discussion. Every allegation was evenly matched with a stern response, every response was countered productively.
Who would have thought before three days that Priyanka Gandhi would have taken a 'Chanakya' jibe on Amit Shah and Amit Shah would burst into laughter. Yes, boss! That happened.
However, though there was a changed and lively tone of the parliament. There was one guy who has been consistent for over 20 years, this guy has never failed to disappoint. Yes, the same guy that you thought of. The one who was narrating his childhood tales of magic and magicians. :)
Comments
Post a Comment